YAY OR NAY WEDNESDAY

Well, last week's discussion about books-turned-films was very interesting- most of us agreed the book is usually better than the film, and that short stories or novellas work better as films than novels do. That said, some adaptations work well- Out of Sight and In Her Shoes, for example. And The Devil Wears Prada has just won Variety Blockbuster Book to Film Award- a special award for books turned into films.

This week, I have another hot book topic for you to discuss! You may not have heard of Macmillan New Writing, but it had publishers and authors all a-flutter earlier this year. It's a low-cost imprint of publisher Macmillan which offers previously unpublished authors little help with proof-reading and publicity, and no advance (so don't give up your day job...) but authors do get  20% of royalties from the sale of their book.

What do you think- is this a great way for new, struggling writers to get into print (more authors get the opportunity as it's very low risk for the publisher) or are writers being ripped off? A great innovation, or only for the desperate?

Do you like the idea, or not- Is it a Yay or a Nay, and why?

[Don't forget it's Yay or Nay day at Hippyshopper, Bridalwave, Corrie Blog, Catwalk Queen, Kiss and Makeup, The Bag Lady, Shoewawa and Shiny Shiny, too!]

YAY OR NAY WEDNESDAY - Comments

  • Nay - the advantage of going with a publisher who pays you a whacking advance is that they have to actively promote your book. With Macmillan, they won&#39t have any incentive to do anything surely?

  • I agree with John. It just seems like a publisher jumping on the vanity publishing bandwagon. Then again it may be easier for an author to get a better deal if they&#39ve been published by Macmillan in any capacity. Still, I wouldn&#39t do it so it&#39ll have to be a nay.

  • It&#39s a NAY from me - it sounds little better than vanity publishing. If they&#39re not going to promote your book then it won&#39t sell, especially beside those by established authors that stand in serried ranks right by the entrance with large billboards attached. I guess it&#39s OK if you want one to give to your Mum for leaving on the coffee table to impress the neighbours.

  • Yay, I think! It&#39s hard to say really without knowing the ins and outs of it, but it&#39s another avenue for writers to follow I suppose - although it seems like they won&#39t really be any better off moneywise - just published!

  • Yes.. well they&#39re certainly all about the money!

    I read authors get about 5% of the cost of a book, I think... might have been less!

blog comments powered by Disqus

Came straight to this page? Visit Trashionista for loads more stories!