YAY OR NAY WEDNESDAY

SenseLast week, we talked about the huge advances given to celebrity authors - and had a pretty lively debate (-- click that link to check it out!)

This week: some more Austen, in Yay or Nay form this time! Please tell me I'm not the only one old enough to remember Emma Thompson's excellent, Oscar-winning film adaptation of Sense and Sensibility? (Okay, it's not that old, just eleven years... same as Emma, clearly Austen has a revival every decade or so.)

I do love that big-screen version, though. So I have mixed feelings about the fact that Andrew Davies, the man who thought to put Colin Firth in a wet shirt, is making a new version for the small screen. Will it be as good as the film? Better? Or have we had Austen adaptation overload?

Tell us what you think: The new S & S: is it a Yay, or a Nay - and why?

Yay or Nay archives.

[Don't forget it's Yay or Nay day at Hippyshopper, Bridalwave, Corrie Blog, Catwalk Queen, Kiss and Makeup, The Bag Lady, Shoewawa and Shiny Shiny, too!]

Posted in Austen Week by

YAY OR NAY WEDNESDAY - Comments

  • this is a great post,i like it very much

  • Yay all the way. I love this adaption. It&#39s difficult to explain it, it&#39s just marvelous. I&#39ve seen the new version and I actually liked that one too in it&#39s own way, because it is impossible to compare them, they are too different but at the same time both really good, I&#39m even leaning towards that I like some parts of the new one better than the Emma Thompson version.

  • Oops. So what I meant to say was &#39Yay!&#39

  • I got a bit upset when I first heard about this, yelling to my housemate (and fellow Austen fan) that "you can&#39t mess with perfection" because I thought Emma Thompson did an amazing job and adore her adaptation.



    But then I thought about it. A whole new cast, possibly an Eleanor who&#39s the right age, a gorgeous new Willoughby, and Andrew Davies with his "I&#39ll get something sexy in there if it kills me" mantra. It&#39s got to be a good thing, right?



    Nobody&#39s going to beat Rickman though, are they?

  • I LOVED the Emma Thompson S&S and can&#39t believe it&#39s 10 years!



    It&#39s a Yay for me. There&#39s enough in Austen to support numerous adaptations and a fresh version every so often will introduce new generations to the books (or help them with their study of them - I watched this S&S when I did my degree).

blog comments powered by Disqus

Came straight to this page? Visit Trashionista for loads more stories!