Snap!

I was interested to read this on Sarah Weinman's Confessions of an Idiosyncratic Mind blog:

Dan Begley's MS. TAKEN IDENTITY, in which a failed male novelist decides to write a chick-lit novel under a female pseudonym, becoming a better man through the process and rocketing to fame and bestsellerdom...

"I'm pretty sure I read this book, or at least a different idea of it, a few years ago..." said Ms Weinman. What book was she talking about?

Colin Bateman's Chapter & Verse, which is the story of a fading author, Ivan Connor, and his bizarre attempt to reignite his career by drunkenly re-editing his rejected literary masterpiece into a chick-lit bonk buster and hiring a beautiful actress to impersonate this new publishing star.

So what do you think? Are they too close for comfort or is there room for lots of different books on similar subjects?

Related posts: Another cover 'snap'! | What's in a name? | Who is Lucy Jackson?

Snap! - Comments

  • Lara

    How many times did Shakespeare recycle the same material? The only thing that matters is if the book is well-written and finds some way of setting itself apart.

  • Lara

    How many times did Shakespeare recycle the same material? The only thing that matters is if the book is well-written and finds some way of setting itself apart.

  • Lara

    How many times did Shakespeare recycle the same material? The only thing that matters is if the book is well-written and finds some way of setting itself apart.

  • I agree with Melanie - if the books are good and not actually plagiarised, then it&#39s OK by me, and inevitable that some people will have the same ideas.



    I love the punnery of MS. TAKEN IDENTITY btw! :)

  • Melanie

    I guess I would have to read both books before making a decision. They say, "There are no new ideas under the sun", which means that eventually ideas will lap and spill into each other. It&#39s all in the way the author presents the work: is it fresh, different and in his/her own voice? They both sound interesting, anyway :)

blog comments powered by Disqus

Came straight to this page? Visit Trashionista for loads more stories!