Some chick lit is good ... when it's written by a man

Just read this and didn't know whether to laugh or cry:

The literary genre known as "chick lit" (think "Bridget Jones's Diary" and "In Her Shoes") is often too simple, too trite. The heroine, usually a clumsy type, always gets her man, and if she doesn't, it's because she learns the true meaning of friendship. But every now and then a chick lit book also happens to tell a great story. For instance, the novel on the agenda for tonight's "Chick Lit Book Discussion Group" ... is premium chick lit. It's called "How To Be Good," and it happens to have been written by a man. You go, Nick Hornby.

I do believe Nick Hornby's first novel, High Fidelity, is basically chick lit (in fact, we included it in our Top 10 chick lit books of all time). But How To Be Good? Not so much.

And isn't it interesting that, with all the chick lit out there (and, yes, some of it is simple and trite, but there is plenty that's neither), a "Chick Lit Book Discussion Group" would pick this book? Almost as if they were embarrassed to be reading chick lit in the first place.

Some chick lit is good ... when it's written by a man - Comments

  • Jana

    I did not care for "How To Be Good". Maybe he was trying so hard to capture that chick lit vibe that he forgot to make the story interesting. If I didn&#39t read very quickly I might even be pissed about the time wasted on this book.

  • well said, Claire! x

  • I HATED and for that read HHAAAATTTEEEDDD How to Be Good...

    It should have been called "How To Be Rubbish" or "How to Be A Book Where Feck All Happens".



    Pah. Philistines.

  • Wow, this is really narrow-minded of this so-called Chick Lit Discussion Group. And I would never have classified How To Be Good as chick lit. It&#39s too dramatic (as in not funny what-so-ever)to be an example of a chick lit book.

  • LOL! I&#39m not sending it to her!

blog comments powered by Disqus

Came straight to this page? Visit Trashionista for loads more stories!